Home

At Church Street Cookies, our top priority is to provide you with the freshest, best-tasting cookies and baked goods that we possibly can! Whether you are looking for decorated sugar cookies for your bridal shower, a cookie cake for a birthday party, or sending a cookie care package to your Cedarville student, this is your place!

We offer a wide variety of artisan cookies and other delicious treats. Some of our cookies include iced sugar, chocolate chunk, ginger molasses (half-dipped in Ghirardelli white chocolate), peanut butter, snickerdoodles, and almond toffee. Other treats include brownies, hand tarts, cream horns, macarons, lemon bars, and more.

The next time you are in the Cedarville area, stop by and say hello!

Gluten Free Also Available

We also offer a nice assortment of Gluten Free and vegan items supplied by Purely Sweet Bakery of Beavercreek. The following are vegan and GF: salted caramel chocolate chip cookie bars, chocolate chip brownies, and oatmeal cream pies. GF: peanut butter cookies.

Order Online

Use our convenient online order form to let us know what we can bake for you, and when you need it. We’ll call you to verify your order, and have it ready for you to pick up at our bakery in Cedarville, Ohio. We do not offer shipping at this time. Thanks for stopping by!